Sorry, you can't recall...

Why Won't My Dog Come When I Call? The Ultimate Guide to Recall Training

"If a dog will not come to you after having looked you in the face, you should go home and examine your conscience." - Winston Churchill

Let's be honest—how many times have you stood in the dog park frustrated calling your dog "Come Here!" only to watch your dog glance at you and then promptly trot in the opposite direction? Or you let your dog out in the middle of the night only to see your puppy get the zoomies or decide it's time to explore while you stand in your underwear trying to convince them to get back inside. If you're nodding along, you're definitely not alone. But here's the thing: maybe it's not entirely your dog's fault.

The Great Assumption: Dogs Should Want to Come When Called

We humans have this expectation that our dogs should naturally want to drop everything and rush to our side the moment we call. But think about it from your dog's perspective for a moment. You're asking them to leave behind a fascinating world of smells, sights, sounds, and social interactions to come stand next to you. What exactly are you offering in return?

The truth is, we're often competing with forces far more powerful than we realize.

Photo by Rafaëlla Waasdorp on Unsplash

What Are You Actually Competing With?

The Environment is Their Netflix

Your dog experiences a sensory world we can barely comprehend. While you see an empty field, your dog smells the rabbit that passed through three hours ago, the spot where another dog marked yesterday, and the remnants of someone's dropped sandwich from last week. We're essentially "nose blind" to the rich tapestry of information that captivates our dogs every second they're outside.

Genetics Don't Lie

What was your dog bred to do? If you've got a Border Collie, they were designed to work independently and make split-second decisions about livestock. If you have a Bloodhound, their nose is literally calling the shots. Fast, capable, brilliant dogs—your sled dogs, hunting breeds, and herding dogs—tend to want a much wider radius of operation than we're comfortable with. Are you fighting thousands of years of selective breeding? Sometimes, yes.

The Anxious Paradox

Here's something counterintuitive: insecure dogs, separation anxiety sufferers, and "Velcro dogs" often have terrible recall. You'd think a clingy dog would always want to be near you, but anxiety can create such internal chaos that they struggle to process and respond to cues effectively.

The Hierarchy of Reinforcers: Food Isn't Always King

Many dog parents assume treats are the ultimate motivator, but food might actually be number three (or lower!) on your dog's personal preference list. For some dogs, the freedom to sniff, chase, or socialize trumps even the tastiest morsel. Understanding what truly motivates your individual dog is crucial to successful recall training.

Common Recall Mistakes We All Make

Poisoned Recall

This happens when "come" becomes code for "fun time is over." If every time you call your dog it means going inside, getting leashed, or ending playtime, you've accidentally taught them that responding to their name equals disappointment. No wonder they pretend not to hear you!

Teaching Them to Ignore You

Raise your hand if you've ever done this: "Bella... Bella... BELLA!" We inadvertently teach our dogs that they don't need to respond to the first call—or even the second or third. You're essentially training them that your cue doesn't require immediate attention.

Proof of Concept Problem

If you've never truly challenged your recall training in gradually increasing distractions, how do you know it actually works when you need it most? Many of us practice in our living room and then wonder why it fails at the dog park.

Ouch, My Ego: You're Not Always the Most Interesting Thing

This one stings a little, but it's liberating once you accept it. Sometimes a pile of leaves, another dog's rear end, or a suspicious squirrel is genuinely more compelling than you are in that moment. And that's okay! It doesn't mean your dog doesn't love you—it means they're being a dog.

Top Tips to Transform Your Recall Game

Body Language and Energy Matter

Your tone, inflection, and body language communicate more than your words. Squat down, open your arms, use your diaphragm to project excitement and joy. Make yourself physically irresistible.

The Magic of Variable Reinforcement

Sometimes give treats, sometimes give praise, sometimes give the jackpot of returning to what they were doing before you called them. This unpredictability keeps them engaged and hopeful.

The Number One Secret

Here it is: during training, frequently let your dog return to exactly what they were doing before you called them. This single strategy will revolutionize their enthusiasm for responding to you. They'll learn that "come" doesn't always mean "party's over."

Making Training Fun Again

If your training has gotten stale, it's time to inject some play:

• Hide and seek: Call them, then hide and let them find you

• Catch me if you can: Call them while jogging away

• Challenge yourself: Remove words, remove gestures, test different distances

• Use their nose: Hide treats and call them to "find it"

Time for Something New?

Maybe you've made every mistake in the book and your dog has figured out your game. If traditional recall isn't working, try teaching an alternative behavior that serves the same function. Instead of "come," teach them to "touch" your hand. The goal is the same—getting a dog who's far away to come close—but without all the negative associations they might have with the word "come."

Consider tools like a long training leash to help you succeed while keeping everyone safe during the learning process.

---

The Step-by-Step Training Guide: Teaching Reliable Recall

Why This Matters

A reliable recall could literally save your dog's life. Whether they've slipped their leash, spotted something interesting across a busy street, or gotten into a dangerous situation, having your dog come when called is the most important safety skill you can teach.

The 5 Golden Rules of Recall Training

1. Never Call Your Dog for Anything Unpleasant

Don't use "come" before nail trims, baths, or ending playtime. Your dog should always associate coming to you with good things happening.

2. Only Call When You're Confident They'll Succeed

Set your dog up for success. If they have beginner-level recall, don't test it around major distractions like squirrels or other dogs playing.

3. Make It Happen If They Don't Respond

If your dog doesn't come when called, don't repeat the cue. Instead, go to them with a treat, get their attention, and guide them back while backing away so they follow you.

4. Never Repeat the Cue

Saying "come, come, COME!" teaches your dog to ignore you. Call once clearly, then use rule #3 if needed.

5. Use Amazing Rewards

Want your dog to leave something exciting? Make coming to you even MORE exciting! Use high-value treats (cheese, hot dogs, cooked chicken) or their favorite toy—not boring dry biscuits.

How to Train Recall: The Method